Clear Commerce

How to Price Products You Sell Online

By the Clear Commerce Editorial Team · Updated November 16, 2026

Man at a workbench comparing candle-making materials while planning prices

To price a product, add up everything it costs you to make one sale, decide how much profit each sale needs to leave you, and then check that buyers would see the result as fair value. After that, test. Price isn't a one-time guess; it's a number you revisit as you learn your real costs and what customers respond to.

Pricing is one of the decisions that quietly makes or breaks a store, which is why it has its own place in our E-commerce section. The steps below work whether you sell handmade goods, printed products or items you buy wholesale.

Step 1: Find your true cost per sale

Most new sellers undercount costs. They remember materials and forget the small charges that come with every order. Build a cost sheet with these lines:

Cost lineWhat to include
Product costMaterials, wholesale cost or print cost per unit
PackagingBox or mailer, tissue, tape, labels, inserts
Platform feesListing, transaction or subscription charges, spread per sale
Payment processingWhat your payment provider charges per order
Shipping you payPostage you cover, fully or partly
Your timeHours to make, pack and answer messages, at a wage you choose
Overhead shareTools, software, samples, supplies used up over time
Returns and damageA small set-aside for items that come back or break

Fees differ by platform and change over time, so look up the current numbers on the platforms you actually use and plug them in. Don't rely on what a friend or forum said.

Your time belongs on the sheet even if you don't pay yourself yet. If you leave it out, you'll build a business that only works while your time is free, and it rarely stays free.

Step 2: Decide the profit each sale needs

Profit is what's left after every cost line above. Ask yourself what each sale needs to leave behind to be worth doing, and to fund growth such as new materials, better tools or a small ad test.

There's no correct number to copy here. It depends on your product, your goals and how many hours you can put in. What matters is that you choose it on purpose instead of discovering at tax time that you broke even. For a look at setting aside money for taxes, see our guide to side hustle taxes, and talk to a tax professional about your own situation.

A worked example (made-up numbers)

This is a made-up example with round numbers chosen for easy math. They are not market prices or typical costs. Riley sells hand-poured candles. Their cost sheet for one candle looks like this:

LineExample amount
Wax, wick, fragrance, jar$4
Packaging$1
Platform and payment fees, spread per sale$2
Shipping Riley covers$0 (buyer pays)
Time: 15 minutes at a chosen $20 an hour$5
Overhead and returns set-aside$1
Total cost per candle$13

Riley decides each candle should leave $7 of profit on top of paying themselves for their time. That points to a price of $20. Next, they check value: do similar handmade candles with comparable jars, scents and presentation sell in that general range? If buyers would clearly see it as fair, $20 is a reasonable starting point. If not, Riley has three honest options: lower costs, improve what the buyer gets, or choose a different product.

Notice what Riley didn't do: start from a competitor's price and work backward until the math "fit." That's how sellers end up losing money on every order without noticing.

Step 3: Check value from the buyer's side

Cost tells you the floor. Value tells you what buyers will accept. To judge value:

  • Look at similar products, not identical ones. Note the materials, size, finish, photos and shipping speed, not only the price.
  • List what makes yours different. Handmade detail, a longer-lasting material, a better fit or faster replies all count.
  • Ask real people. Show the product and ask, "What would you expect to pay for this?" before you say your price.
  • Watch how you present it. Clear product photos and detailed descriptions help buyers see why a price makes sense.

Step 4: Choose a pricing approach

ApproachHow it worksWhen it fits
Cost-plusTotal cost plus your chosen profitA simple, safe start for most new sellers
Value-basedPriced on what the outcome is worth to the buyerUnique, custom or premium items
TieredGood, better, best versionsProducts with sizes, bundles or add-ons
BundlesSeveral items together for one priceSets, refills, gift packs

You can combine these. Many small shops start with cost-plus, then add a bundle or a premium version once they understand what buyers like. The same thinking applies to digital goods, with very different costs; our guide to pricing digital products covers that side.

Step 5: Test prices carefully

Testing beats guessing, but random changes teach you nothing. A simple test plan:

  1. Change one thing at a time: the price, a bundle, or a shipping offer, never all three.
  2. Write down the date, the old price and the new one.
  3. Give it time. A few days of slow sales is noise, not a verdict.
  4. Look at profit, not just the number of orders. Fewer sales at a higher price can leave you better off.
  5. Treat customers fairly. Don't show different prices to people in misleading ways or invent fake "was" prices.

Pricing claims count as advertising, and the FTC expects advertising to be truthful; our guide to copywriting basics explains what that means. Avoid fake countdown timers, made-up original prices and pressure tactics. If you see a course promising a pricing trick that makes buyers unable to say no, read our red flags checklist first.

Prices connect to shipping and returns

Two policies affect your price more than most sellers expect:

  • Shipping. If you offer free shipping, the postage still has to come from somewhere, usually your price. Read shipping basics to decide who pays and how to build it in.
  • Returns. A generous return window builds trust, and it has a cost. Your return policy and your set-aside for returns should agree with each other.

Common pricing mistakes

  • Leaving your time off the cost sheet.
  • Forgetting fees on the shipping portion of an order, if your platform charges them.
  • Pricing to beat the cheapest seller in a search result.
  • Never revisiting prices after material costs rise.
  • Running a discount so often that buyers wait for it.

Do this today

Open a spreadsheet and build the cost sheet above for your best-selling or most important product. Fill in every line with real numbers from your receipts and your platform's current fee page. Then compare your total cost with your current price. If the gap doesn't match the profit you want, you've found the first thing to fix.

Partner offer · paid placement

Want a step-by-step business course?

Some people like the structure of a paid guide. This button opens a third-party online business program from one of our advertising partners. Results vary and most people earn little or nothing at first. Its claims are its own, not ours, so weigh them against our red flags checklist.

See the partner program →

We may be paid when you click. The program shown can change. Read its terms before you buy anything. How this works

Frequently asked questions

What is the simplest way to price a product?

Add up the full cost of one sale, including materials, packaging, platform and payment fees, shipping you cover and your time. Add the profit you need per sale, then check whether buyers would see that price as fair for what they get.

Should I price lower than my competitors?

Not by default. Low prices can leave no room for fees, returns or your time, and they're hard to raise later. Compete on clarity, quality and service first, and only cut price when your numbers still work.

How often should I change my prices?

Review prices when your costs change, and run planned tests rather than frequent random changes. Give each test enough time and sales to tell you something before you decide.

See a partner coursePartner offer
Partner offer · paid placement

Want to see a business course?

If you'd like more structure than articles can give, you can look at a third-party business course from one of our partners. Its claims are its own. No pressure: our free guides aren't going anywhere.

See the partner program →

We may be paid when you click. How this works